Separate Opinion of Judge Shahabuddeen

57

SEPARATE OPINION OF JUDGE SHAHABUDDEEN

1agreewiththe Court'sdecisionbut propose to recordsomeadditional
viewsdirected to matters of approach and perspective in respect of two
points.The firstrelatestothe stageatwhichthe dispute materialized. The
secondrelates to the questionwhether the dispute wasoneconcerningthe

interpretation or application ofthe Headquarters Agreement.

Dissenting Opinion of Judge Morozov

DISSENTING OPINION OF JUDGE MOROZOV

1. 1voted against the Advisory Opinion because in substance it is an

attempt to involve the Court to a greater or less extent in the handling of
the serious political conflict existing in the MiddleEast between a number
of States, and particularly States Members of the World Health Organi-
zation, relating to the question of the transfer of its Regional Office
for the Eastern Mediterranean from the terntory of Egypt for political
reasons.

Separate Opinion of Judge El-Erian

SEPARATE OPINION OF JUDGE EL-ERIAN

1concurin the Opinion of the Court. 1amin agreement with the analysis
of the facts of thecase,the statement of the applicableprinciples of law and
the precise and clear replies furnished by the Opinion.1am moved to write
a separate opinion, first to elaborate on a few preliminary questions, and
second to relate some of the points raised in the Opinion to the general law
of international organizations.

Links