Dissenting Opinion of Vice-President Ammoun (translation)
DISSENTING OPINION OF VICE-PRESIDENT AMMOUN
(Translation]
DISSENTING OPINION OF VICE-PRESIDENT AMMOUN
(Translation]
SEPARATE OPINION OF JUDGE JIMÉNEZ DE ARÉCHAGA
SEPARATE OPINION OF JUDGE DILLARD
I agree with the decision and operative clauses of the Opinion. 1 am
prompted to add a separate opinion only because in some respects the
reasons which have led me to agree donot coincidewith those revealed in
the Opinion. As will appear, this separate opinion is concerned lesswith
an analysis of facts than with matters of emphasis and with certain
theoretical considerations bearing on one of the two principal questions
addressed to the Court.
SEPARATE OPINION OF JUDGE ONYEAMA
1have voted on the merits of the Opinion notwithstanding that I do
not agree with the Opinion on the view it takes on the question of
jurisdiction: in my view, it is for the Court, under Article 36, paragra6,
of the Statute of the Court, to settle the question of jurisdiction. Its
President LA CH^ makes the following declaration:
While 1am in full agreement with the reasoning and conclusions of the
President LA CH^ makes the following declaration:
While 1am in full agreement with the reasoning and conclusions of the
DISSENTING OPINION OF JUDGE BUSTAMAKTE
[Translation]
DISSENTING OPINION BY JUDGE KORETSKY
1 regret that 1cannot agree with the Opinion of the Court both
(a) as 1 do not consider that the Court would and should give an
opinion on the given question posed to it by the General Assembly
of the United Nations, and (b) as the Court, to my mind, did not
DISSENTING OPINION OF JUDGE MORENO QUINTANA
[Translation]
DISSENTING OPINION OF JUDGE BASDEVANT