Declaration of Judge Iwasawa
DECLARATION OF JUDGE IWASAWA
Right of peoples to self-determination Free and genuine expression of the will of the people concerned Principle of territorial integrity Discretion to give an advisory opinion Principle of consent in judicial settlement.
Declaration of Judge Salam
DECLARATION OF JUDGE SALAM
Agreement with the operative part of the Opinion Broad agreement with the reasoning of the Court Binding nature of General Assembly resolution 1514 (XV) as a result of its endorsement by Security Council resolutions Question of the possibility of compensation for the Chagossians.
1. Although I voted in favour of all the subparagraphs of the operative part of the present Advisory Opinion and essentially concur with the Court’s reasoning, I consider it necessary to clarify certain points that should have been addressed by the Court.
Declaration of Judge Gevorgian
DECLARATION OF JUDGE GEVORGIAN
The present Opinion makes an important contribution to the law of decolonization and to the Court’s advisory function The unnecessary statement of responsibility made in paragraph 177 blurs the distinction between the Court’s advisory and contentious jurisdiction.
Separate opinion of Judge Robinson
SEPARATE OPINION OF JUDGE ROBINSON
Right to self-determination under customary international law Importance of pre-1960
General Assembly resolutions in the development of the right to self-determination as a rule of
customary international law Role of the Declaration on the Granting of Independence to
Colonial Countries and Peoples (resolution 1514 (XV)) in the development of the right to
self-determination as a rule of customary international law Whether purported consent to the