Dissenting opinion of Vice-President Weeramantry

Document Number
110-19990602-ORD-01-06-EN
Parent Document Number
110-19990602-ORD-01-00-EN
Document File
Bilingual Document File

DISSENTING OPINION OF VICE-PRESIDENT
WEERAMANTRY

My opinion in this case is theame, mutatis mutandis, as that which

1 have delivered in Yugosluviu v. Belgium.

1 do not need to repeat the text of that opinion here and it will suffice
to observe that al1tha1have said there applies equally to this case, and
should be considered to be incorporatedtatis mutandis in this opinion.
In the result1dissent from the Court's Order dismissing the applica-
tion for provisional measures and hold that provisional measures should
have been issued for the reasons and in the manner indicated in my
opinion in Yugoslaviu v. Belgium.

(Signed) Christopher G. WEERAMANTRY

Bilingual Content

DISSENTING OPINION OF VICE-PRESIDENT
WEERAMANTRY

My opinion in this case is theame, mutatis mutandis, as that which

1 have delivered in Yugosluviu v. Belgium.

1 do not need to repeat the text of that opinion here and it will suffice
to observe that al1tha1have said there applies equally to this case, and
should be considered to be incorporatedtatis mutandis in this opinion.
In the result1dissent from the Court's Order dismissing the applica-
tion for provisional measures and hold that provisional measures should
have been issued for the reasons and in the manner indicated in my
opinion in Yugoslaviu v. Belgium.

(Signed) Christopher G. WEERAMANTRY OPINION DISSIDENTE DE M. WEERAMANTRY:

VICE-PRÉSIDENT

[ Truductionj

Mon opinion est dans la présenteaffaire la même,mutatis mutandis,
que celle que j'ai jointà l'ordonnance dans l'affaire Yougoslaviec. Bel-
gique.
Je n'ai pas lieu de répéterici le texte de cette opinion et il me suffit
d'indiquer que tout ce que j'y dis s'applique aussi la présenteespèce,et
doit êtreconsidérécomme intégré mutatis mutandis à la présenteopinion.
C'est-à-dire queje ne souscris pas l'ordonnance dans laquelle la Cour
rejette la requêteen indication de mesures conservatoires car j'estime,
pour les raisons que j'ai exposéesdans l'affaire Yougoslavie c.Belgique,
qu'elle aurait dû indiquer de telles mesures, en leur donnant la forme que

j'ai également définie.

(Signé) Christopher G. WEERAMANTRY

Document file FR
Document Long Title

Dissenting opinion of Vice-President Weeramantry

Links