Declaration of Vice-President Oda

Document Number
078-19930614-JUD-01-01-EN
Parent Document Number
078-19930614-JUD-01-00-EN
Document File
Bilingual Document File

DECLARATION OF VICE-PRESIDENT ODA

Myview,asappears inmyseparate opinion,isthat the DanishApplica-

tion was misconceivedand that the case should havebeen dismissed. As
this viewdid not prevail,the Court hasaken a decision on the substance
of the case.drawine aoarticular line of delimitation the choice of which
does notaipear tomeiobe founded onanyjustifiable reasoning.Consid-
ering, however, ihatthe line in question does lie withinthe infinite range
ofthose ~ossibilitieswhichcould have beenselectedbvthe Parties ifthev
had reached agreement,1havedecided that itisproPeiforme tovotewith
the majority despite mydifference of opinion on severalpoints.

(Signed)Shigem ODA.

Bilingual Content

DECLARATION OF VICE-PRESIDENT ODA

Myview,asappears inmyseparate opinion,isthat the DanishApplica-

tion was misconceivedand that the case should havebeen dismissed. As
this viewdid not prevail,the Court hasaken a decision on the substance
of the case.drawine aoarticular line of delimitation the choice of which
does notaipear tomeiobe founded onanyjustifiable reasoning.Consid-
ering, however, ihatthe line in question does lie withinthe infinite range
ofthose ~ossibilitieswhichcould have beenselectedbvthe Parties ifthev
had reached agreement,1havedecided that itisproPeiforme tovotewith
the majority despite mydifference of opinion on severalpoints.

(Signed)Shigem ODA. DÉCLARATION DE M. ODA, VICE-PRÉSIDENT

[Traduction]

Monavis,tel queje l'aiexprimédans mon opinionindividuelle, estque
larequêtedu Danemarkétaimt al conçueetaurait dû rejetée.Comme
cet avis n'a pas prévalu,la Cour a rendu une décision sur le fond de
l'affaire,entraçant une ligneparticulièrede délimitationdontlechoix ne
me semble pas êtrefondé sur une motivation justifiable. Considérant
toutefoisque laligneenquestion s'incritdans lagammeinfinie despossi-
bilitésqui auraient pii êtrechoisies par les Parties si ellesétaientparve-
nues àun accord, j'ai décidéqu'il serait sage pour moi de voter avec la
majoritéen dépitde mes divergencesd'opinion sur plusieurs points.

(SignéSh)igem ODA.

Document file FR
Document Long Title

Declaration of Vice-President Oda

Links